TehilimTehilim · PsalmPsaume 58

Is there a God who judges the earth

תְּהִלִּים נ״ח

לַמְנַצֵּחַ אַל

Guitar suggestion, hover a chord to explore or changeSuggestion guitare : touche un accord pour l'explorer ou le changer
TuningAccordage E A D G B E
~70 BPM · 4/4 · gentle thumb-index-middle arpeggio · one bar per stich, two bars per verse · to reset the progression: ↺ restore default · to reset the chord panel:pour remettre le panneau d'accords :
Active voicings · printableDoigtés actifs · imprimables
The voicing displayed for each chord is the one you selected in its popup. Navigate with the popup arrows to change.Le doigté affiché pour chaque accord est celui choisi dans sa fenêtre. Change-le avec les flèches de la fenêtre.

Twelve verses aimed at judges who have stopped judging. It opens as a question put to the bench, runs through a chain of images for what corrupt power actually is, turns into a curse, and ends with a verdict spoken by ordinary bystanders. The psalm has no fixed place in the service, so most readers meet it going through the book in order. Two things to watch. The words al tashcheth in the heading, do not destroy, also head psalms 57, 59 and 75, and are usually taken as the name of a tune rather than a plea. And three of the four verbs addressed to the judges in verses 2 and 3 end in an extra nun, an old poetic ending that lengthens the line without changing the sense.

1
לַמְנַצֵּחַ אַל תַּשְׁחֵת

lam-na-TZE-ach al tash-CHET

For the leader. On al tashcheth, do not destroy.

לְדָוִד מִכְתָּם

le-da-VID mich-TAM

Of David. A michtam.

The heading is a tune name rather than an instruction to the reader. The same two words head four psalms, three of them consecutive, and the sense of michtam is not known.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
לַמְנַצֵּחַlam-na-TZE-achfor the leader
אַלaldo not
תַּשְׁחֵתtash-CHETdestroy
לְדָוִדle-da-VIDof David
מִכְתָּםmich-TAMa michtam
2
הַאֻמְנָם אֵלֶם צֶדֶק תְּדַבֵּרוּן

ha-um-NAM E-lem TZE-dek te-da-be-RUN

Is it truly in silence that you speak what is right?

מֵישָׁרִים תִּשְׁפְּטוּ בְּנֵי אָדָם

mei-sha-RIM tish-PTU bnei a-DAM

Do you judge the sons of man with equity?

The psalm opens by cross-examining the court. The first word is the interrogative that expects the answer no, and the question is not whether these judges can judge but whether they ever meant to.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
הַאֻמְנָםha-um-NAMis it truly
אֵלֶםE-lemsilence
צֶדֶקTZE-dekrighteousness
תְּדַבֵּרוּןte-da-be-RUNdo you speak
מֵישָׁרִיםmei-sha-RIMwith equity
תִּשְׁפְּטוּtish-PTUdo you judge
בְּנֵיbneithe sons of
אָדָםa-DAMman
3
אַף בְּלֵב עוֹלֹת תִּפְעָלוּן

af blev o-LOT tif-a-LUN

Indeed, in the heart you work out injustice;

בָּאָרֶץ חֲמַס יְדֵיכֶם תְּפַלֵּסוּן

ba-A-retz cha-MAS ye-DEI-chem tfa-le-SUN

in the land you weigh out the violence of your hands.

The answer to the question. The last verb is a scale verb: the instrument that should be measuring justice is measuring how much violence the hands can deliver.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
אַףafindeed
בְּלֵבblevin the heart
עוֹלֹתo-LOTacts of injustice
תִּפְעָלוּןtif-a-LUNyou work
בָּאָרֶץba-A-retzin the land
חֲמַסcha-MASthe violence of
יְדֵיכֶםye-DEI-chemyour hands
תְּפַלֵּסוּןtfa-le-SUNyou weigh out
4
זֹרוּ רְשָׁעִים מֵרָחֶם

zo-RU re-sha-IM me-RA-chem

The wicked are estranged from the womb;

תָּעוּ מִבֶּטֶן דֹּבְרֵי כָזָב

ta-U mi-BE-ten dov-REI cha-ZAV

the speakers of lies go astray from birth.

From what they do to what they are. The claim is pushed back to birth, which is read either as hyperbole about how set a habit becomes or as a statement about origin, and the two readings have never been reconciled.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
זֹרוּzo-RUare estranged
רְשָׁעִיםre-sha-IMthe wicked
מֵרָחֶםme-RA-chemfrom the womb
תָּעוּta-Uthey go astray
מִבֶּטֶןmi-BE-tenfrom the belly
דֹּבְרֵיdov-REIthe speakers of
כָזָבcha-ZAVlies
5
חֲמַת לָמוֹ כִּדְמוּת חֲמַת נָחָשׁ

cha-MAT la-MO kid-MUT cha-MAT na-CHASH

Their venom is like the venom of a serpent,

כְּמוֹ פֶתֶן חֵרֵשׁ יַאְטֵם אׇזְנוֹ

kmo FE-ten che-RESH ya-TEM oz-NO

like a deaf cobra that stops up its ear,

The first simile is chosen for the ear rather than the eye. Venom accounts for the damage; deafness accounts for why nothing gets through.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
חֲמַתcha-MATthe venom of
לָמוֹla-MOthem
כִּדְמוּתkid-MUTis like the likeness of
חֲמַתcha-MATthe venom of
נָחָשׁna-CHASHa serpent
כְּמוֹkmolike
פֶתֶןFE-tena cobra
חֵרֵשׁche-RESHdeaf
יַאְטֵםya-TEMthat stops up
אׇזְנוֹoz-NOits ear
6
אֲשֶׁר לֹא יִשְׁמַע לְקוֹל מְלַחֲשִׁים

A-sher lo YISH-ma le-KOL mla-cha-SHIM

which does not listen to the voice of charmers,

חוֹבֵר חֲבָרִים מְחֻכָּם

cho-VER cha-va-RIM me-chu-KAM

or to a skilled binder of spells.

The cobra image is completed, and the detail is precise. Snake charming was a working trade, so this is not a creature nobody could reach. It is a creature that will not be reached.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
אֲשֶׁרA-sherwhich
לֹאlodoes not
יִשְׁמַעYISH-malisten
לְקוֹלle-KOLto the voice of
מְלַחֲשִׁיםmla-cha-SHIMcharmers
חוֹבֵרcho-VERa binder of
חֲבָרִיםcha-va-RIMspells
מְחֻכָּםme-chu-KAMskilled
7
אֱלֹהִים הֲרׇס שִׁנֵּימוֹ בְּפִימוֹ

e-lo-HIM ha-ROS shi-nei-MO be-fi-MO

God, break their teeth in their mouth;

מַלְתְּעוֹת כְּפִירִים נְתֹץ יְהֹוָה

mal-te-OT kfi-RIM ne-TOTZ a-do-NAY

smash the fangs of the young lions, LORD.

The turn. Six verses of description end and the asking begins, with two demolition verbs, the kind used on walls and altars, applied here to a mouth.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
אֱלֹהִיםe-lo-HIMGod
הֲרׇסha-ROSbreak
שִׁנֵּימוֹshi-nei-MOtheir teeth
בְּפִימוֹbe-fi-MOin their mouth
מַלְתְּעוֹתmal-te-OTthe fangs of
כְּפִירִיםkfi-RIMyoung lions
נְתֹץne-TOTZsmash
יְהֹוָהa-do-NAYthe LORD
8
יִמָּאֲסוּ כְמוֹ מַיִם יִתְהַלְּכוּ לָמוֹ

yi-ma-a-SU che-MO MA-yim yit-hal-CHU la-MO

Let them dissolve like water that drains away;

יִדְרֹךְ חִצָּו כְּמוֹ יִתְמֹלָלוּ

yid-ROCH chi-TZAV kmo yit-mo-la-LU

when he aims his arrows, let them be cut down.

The requests are all about disappearance rather than punishment. Water that drains away leaves nothing behind to bury.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
יִמָּאֲסוּyi-ma-a-SUlet them dissolve
כְמוֹche-MOlike
מַיִםMA-yimwater
יִתְהַלְּכוּyit-hal-CHUthat flows off
לָמוֹla-MOfor themselves
יִדְרֹךְyid-ROCHlet him aim
חִצָּוchi-TZAVhis arrows
כְּמוֹkmoas if
יִתְמֹלָלוּyit-mo-la-LUlet them be cut down
9
כְּמוֹ שַׁבְּלוּל תֶּמֶס יַהֲלֹךְ

kmo shab-LUL TE-mes ya-ha-LOCH

Like a snail that melts as it goes,

נֵפֶל אֵשֶׁת בַּל חָזוּ שָׁמֶשׁ

NE-fel E-shet bal cha-ZU SHA-mesh

like a woman's stillbirth that never saw the sun.

Two more images of vanishing, both taken from things that were never fully there. The snail image is usually explained by the trail it leaves, read as the animal melting away as it moves.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
כְּמוֹkmolike
שַׁבְּלוּלshab-LULa snail
תֶּמֶסTE-mesa melting
יַהֲלֹךְya-ha-LOCHlet it go
נֵפֶלNE-felthe stillbirth of
אֵשֶׁתE-sheta woman
בַּלbalnever
חָזוּcha-ZUthey have seen
שָׁמֶשׁSHA-meshthe sun
10
בְּטֶרֶם יָבִינוּ סִּירֹתֵכֶם אָטָד

be-TE-rem ya-vi-NU si-ro-TE-chem a-TAD

Before your pots can feel the thornbush,

כְּמוֹ חַי כְּמוֹ חָרוֹן יִשְׂעָרֶנּוּ

kmo chai kmo cha-RON yis-a-re-NU

raw or burning, He will sweep it away.

The hardest verse in the psalm and one of the hardest in the book. Translations ancient and modern do not agree on it, and the disagreement is about the plain sense, not the nuance.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
בְּטֶרֶםbe-TE-rembefore
יָבִינוּya-vi-NUthey can feel
סִּירֹתֵכֶםsi-ro-TE-chemyour pots
אָטָדa-TADthe thornbush
כְּמוֹkmoas
חַיchailiving
כְּמוֹkmoas
חָרוֹןcha-RONburning
יִשְׂעָרֶנּוּyis-a-re-NUHe will sweep it away
11
יִשְׂמַח צַדִּיק כִּי חָזָה נָקָם

yis-MACH tza-DIK ki cha-ZA na-KAM

The righteous will rejoice when he sees the vengeance,

פְּעָמָיו יִרְחַץ בְּדַם הָרָשָׁע

pe-a-MAV yir-CHATZ bdam ha-ra-SHA

he will bathe his feet in the blood of the wicked.

The verse most readers stumble on. What is celebrated is the verdict, but the psalm refuses to keep the picture clean: it puts the righteous man on his feet in the middle of the field.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
יִשְׂמַחyis-MACHshall rejoice
צַדִּיקtza-DIKa righteous one
כִּיkiwhen
חָזָהcha-ZAhe has seen
נָקָםna-KAMvengeance
פְּעָמָיוpe-a-MAVhis feet
יִרְחַץyir-CHATZhe shall wash
בְּדַםbdamin the blood of
הָרָשָׁעha-ra-SHAthe wicked one
12
וְיֹאמַר אָדָם אַךְ פְּרִי לַצַּדִּיק

ve-yo-MAR a-DAM ach pri la-tza-DIK

And a man will say: there is fruit for the righteous after all;

אַךְ יֵשׁ אֱלֹהִים שֹׁפְטִים בָּאָרֶץ

ach yesh e-lo-HIM shof-TIM ba-A-retz

there is, after all, a God who judges in the earth.

The conclusion is handed to nobody in particular. Not the judges, not the righteous, but a person, the same word as the sons of man the corrupt court was supposed to be judging in verse 2.

Word by wordMot à mot
HebrewReadingMeaning
וְיֹאמַרve-yo-MARand he will say
אָדָםa-DAMa person
אַךְachsurely
פְּרִיprifruit
לַצַּדִּיקla-tza-DIKfor the righteous
אַךְachsurely
יֵשׁyeshthere is
אֱלֹהִיםe-lo-HIMGod
שֹׁפְטִיםshof-TIMjudging
בָּאָרֶץba-A-retzin the earth
Four readings (PaRDeS)Quatre lectures (PaRDeS)

The four levels of Jewish reading of the sacred text: פשט Peshat (literal meaning), רמז Remez (symbolic allusion), דרש Drash (midrashic interpretation), סוד Sod (mystical meaning). The word פרדס means "orchard", each level is a fruit.

פשט · Peshat: literal meaning

Four movements. Verses 2 and 3 question a court and then answer their own question. Verses 4 to 6 describe the judges as a species rather than as people, estranged from the womb and deaf by choice. Verses 7 to 10 ask God to disarm them, and every request is a subtraction: teeth out, water drained, a snail gone, a birth that never saw daylight. Verses 11 and 12 step outside the courtroom and report what onlookers conclude. The frame is worth reading twice. The psalm opens with בְּנֵי (bnei, v.2) and אָדָם (a-dam, v.2), the sons of man, as the people being judged, and ends with אָדָם (a-dam, v.12), a man, as the one pronouncing the verdict on the judges. The bench and the public have changed places.

רמז · Remez: allusion

Two cruxes and one grammatical tic. The first crux is אֵלֶם (e-lem, v.2). The Masoretic vocalization gives the noun for silence, which is how the older translations read the line, while many modern ones revocalize the same consonants as a plural for gods or mighty ones and take the line as a direct address to the judges themselves. The consonants allow both and the reading is disputed. The second is verse 10, where סִּירֹתֵכֶם (si-ro-te-chem, v.10), your pots, אָטָד (a-tad, v.10), thornbush, and חָרוֹן (cha-ron, v.10), which is the ordinary word for burning anger but here may only mean heat, combine into a sentence nobody has settled. The tic is the extra nun on תְּדַבֵּרוּן (te-da-be-run, v.2), תִּפְעָלוּן (tif-a-lun, v.3) and תְּפַלֵּסוּן (tfa-le-sun, v.3), a poetic ending that adds weight rather than meaning, and all three of those verbs are aimed at the judges.

דרש · Drash: midrashic reading

The deaf cobra of verses 5 and 6 became a standard image for someone who has heard the argument and sealed the ear on purpose, which is a heavier charge than ignorance. The charmer of חוֹבֵר (cho-ver, v.6) and חֲבָרִים (cha-va-rim, v.6) is a working professional, not a magician in a story, and that is the force of the image: the technique exists, and this creature is immune to it. The last verse turns on a grammatical oddity. שֹׁפְטִים (shof-tim, v.12) is a plural participle, judging, attached to a subject usually treated as singular. The same word for God is used elsewhere in the Torah for human judges, in the courtroom passages of Exodus 22, so the closing line can be heard as saying that God judges the earth, or that there are judges in it after all. Which of the two the verse intends is not settled.

סוד · Sod: mystical reading

Read as a map of one faculty, the psalm is about the ear and the mouth. The judges are asked about their speech in verse 2, they weigh violence with their hands in verse 3, and by verse 5 they have become a creature that has closed the single opening through which correction could arrive, אׇזְנוֹ (oz-no, v.5), its ear. The requests of verses 7 to 10 all attack that same head: the teeth inside the mouth, then the fangs, then the whole body run off as water. What is asked for is not pain but the removal of an instrument. The close reverses the direction. Speech comes back, but from outside the court, and the psalm ends on a mouth that says something true after eleven verses of mouths that could not.

Hebrew text: Miqra according to the Masorah (MAM), after the Aleppo Codex, via Sefaria, CC BY-SA. English: The Holy Scriptures, a New Translation (JPS 1917), via Sefaria, public domain. Transliteration generated by this site's own engine (assets/translit.js).